We wrote the following letter to the Japan Times in response to
articles and editorials that we had been reading in the paper. We understand that it was
printed but didn't have the opportunity to see it, so we have no idea how it was
edited.The accompanying picture was taken at the Takeda Shingen parade. The jacket was
worn by a young man who was assisting a person with a disability. We had seen the graphic
on clothing frequently, but were taken aback by the juxtaposition.
_____________________________
April 20, 1996
Dear Editor:
We are an American couple living in Japan. We have a 22-year
relationship with Japan, and presently we are in the 9th month of a one-year stay. We have
a great love for Japan and count some of our Japanese friends among our extended family.
Both of us are social scientists, and we have each dedicated
our professional and personal lives to helping people better understand each other and to
bridging gaps in relationships. One of us is a psychologist, the other a political
scientist/educator. One of our proudest accomplishments is the founding of two exchange
programs between U.S. and Japanese schools, both of which are more than twenty years old.
We have traveled to Vietnam, China, South Korea, India, Europe, Canada, Australia, and
Hong Kong, but have the most intimate relationship with this country. It is from this
perspective that we read the Japan Times daily
Can you imagine our chagrin when we came across Mr.
Kobayashi's letter of 4/15? Likewise, the concern expressed in Ms. Hansen's letter struck
an uncomfortable cord.
It is silly to suggest that the U.S. really wants
"world conquest" as stated by Mr. Kobayashi, and it is not worth rebuttal.
However, his sentiment is another matter.
Our immediate concern is about xenophobia that encourages
fear, distrust, misunderstanding, hate, and ongoing strife among people and among nations.
Not only does Mr. Kobayashi's letter blatantly promote xenophobia, but the clothing
apparel described by Ms. Hansen, perhaps more subtly, does the same.
We are appalled when we see that popular shirt. It obviously
presents a violent and misogynist message. Even if one does not understand what the word bitch
means, the graphic is very clear.
How many ways can one interpret a man holding a gun to a
woman's head? We are confused about why anyone would wear clothing bearing such a message?
Why is there a market for this clothing in Japan? Who is promoting it? It is rather
frightening that a market exists for it.
However, it is only one example of many negative
representations of Westerners, and specifically Americans, that we have seen or
experienced during our present stay.... in the media, in advertising, and expressed in day
to day life.
One beauty of being American is that we feel free to
criticize ourselves, to state honestly that we have many problems in our
society....violence, discrimination against minorities, and economic inequities. We are
aware of our problems and talk about them openly. That is part of a functioning democracy.
However, we have observed these same problems in every country we have visited, including
Japan.
When others take advantage of our openness and point fingers
at us, with the implication that their nation is superior, or without similar domestic
problems, it promotes divisiveness among people and nations, as well as perpetuating their
country's domestic problems.
For example, why did Health Ministry officials and medical
professionals wish the people to believe that AIDS first came to Japan via the U.S.,
rather than telling the truth? Why were so many, including the media, so willing to
believe that explanation, without looking further into the issue? Honest self-examination
with a willingness to learn from that, and then make the necessary changes, (not just lip
service) goes a long way in promoting health, peace and harmony both at home and among
nations.
We think that we need to learn from each other, study each
other's culture and history, communicate with each other, rather than try to find someone
outside ourselves to blame for our problems.
Perhaps, better self-awareness and treating each other with
dignity and respect, rather than name-calling, will help us inch our way toward
international peace.
Sincerely,
Tom and Marie Grant
Update 1999:
While in Japan we read the Japan Times daily, as we mentioned above.
However, since returning to the US, we much prefer the Asahi Shimbun.